2017 Macbook Pro vs Lenovo X1 Carbon

I’ve been using a latest model Macbook Pro for the last 6 months or so now and have recently got my hands on a Lenovo X1 Carbon (6th gen). So here’s a comparison of the two from a software engineering perspective.

Macbook Pro specification:

  • 3.5GHz Intel i7 CPU
  • 16GB RAM
  • 1TB SSD
  • 13in screen (retina)
  • Priced around £2800

X1 Carbon specification:

  • Intel Core i7-8650U Processor (8MB Cache, up to 4.2GHz)
  • 16GB RAM
  • 1TB SSD
  • 14in screen (HDR)
  • Priced around £2600

The main worry I had with the X1 Carbon was that the screen wouldn’t have the vibrant brightness of the Mac. However I was pleased to find the X1 screen brightness matches that of the Mac.

The Mac keyboard was a true pain point. Every couple of days a random key would just stop functioning. This is clearly a design flaw, with small amounts of dust under the keys causing them to not work. Apple posted this “fix” for the issue which works but is a chore to keep blasting the keyboard to keep it working,

The X1 Carbon keyboard on the other hand has been a dream to work with. The keys are much more raised up than those of the Mac which feels nicer to type on. It’s also better to have a REAL “Esc” key to reach for, which is missing from the Mac as it’s now built into the touch-bar.

Ports. The Mac has a headphone jack along with a bunch of USB-C ports which forced me to spend on additional adapters. The X1 Carbon comes with USB, USB-C, HDMI, headphone jack and an SD card slot on the back. Enough said.

Cooling. The Mac external design looks great, but it lacks some good ventilation. Under high load the base of the Aluminum case can get quite hot — not good when you’re not using the laptop on a desk. The X1 Carbon has some big beefy vents on the side which seem to do a good job — just be careful not to place your fingers over the vents as they chuck out the hot air.

Overall. Both are great laptops, but due to the ports issue (which Apple are taking the piss with) along with the broken keyboard design means I’m going to make the X1 Carbon my primary laptop going forward.

Hopefully this was useful to someone. Post a comment below if you have any experience with either laptop.

6 thoughts on “2017 Macbook Pro vs Lenovo X1 Carbon

  1. jacobmackwen

    Great in-depth post! about the Lenovo laptop.As I have been using a Lenovo laptop for a very long time and facing a lenovo battery lithium cells issue. Above discussed blog was a great help to me and contacting Lenovo Customer Support will also provide an instant solution for such issues.
    Keep up the good work. Thanks

    Reply
  2. Nathan

    This was very helpful thank you, I’m considering both of those computers and this helped me make up my mind. One question – does the 16:9 screen ratio of the Lenovo bother you at all? Do you find it noticeably different than the 16:10 of the Mac book?

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*